Christ. Apparently I have nothing of interest to write in this lonesome and desolate blog that I am resorting to writing a book review. Seriously? Although my ability to read has been called in to question on numerous occasions, I can assure you that I am quite proficient in the art of, well, reading, and that I am more than capable of writing a review of the literary merits of the novel that I have recently finished. I mean, look at how well I wrote those first couple of sentences! You can’t write beautiful, flowing words such as those if you’ve never read a book! I, however, understand your skepticism. Regardless, New York Times, be ready to hire me on, because this may be the best damn book review you have ever laid eyes upon. Probably not, but hey, why not reach for the stars, even though you may be too deep underground to see the sky? There’s wisdom in those words that I just made up, kids - I’m sure of it.
Imagine an American Harry Potter. Got that in your mind? Ok, now imagine an American Narnia. Still with me? Ok, combine the two into one story. Now here is where I might lose you: add young adult alcoholism and lots of fucking to that story. Blew your mind? No? Good, lets move on now that I have your attention.
I’m not going to go into a plot summary; that’s insulting to your ability to use Google. I will, however, go over some pros and cons, strengths and weaknesses. Be warned: There are some spoilers, and if you have not read the story, this “review” may very well ruin the ending for you.
The story is wonderfully told by Lev Grossman (the author). You see this world of magic through the eyes of 17 year old protagonist, Quentin Coldwater. You see everything he sees from his introduction to the world of magic, to his schooling in magic, and his life after he leaves school. Its a great coming of age tale where the protagonist is not in any way a saint. Its very ‘real world’ with a lot of fairy tale-ness of other stories similar to this removed. That is one of the things I greatly enjoyed about this book. I mean, in the 7th Harry Potter book Ron said ‘bloody’ and ‘hell’ quite a few times, but if I was fighting Lord Voldemort (one of my personal heroes), or saw a good friend get murdered (poor Fred), you can bet I’d be dropping F-Bombs left and right; English etiquette be damned!
A couple of notes on Mr. Grossman’s writing style. A dear friend of mine pointed out that he uses way too many adjectives. This is absolutely true. But, at the same time, you would think with that many adjectives he would reach Tolkien level of detail. Sometimes it seemed to me that he skimmed on details because he seemed so intent on getting to the next part of the story; maybe one that interested him more than the part he was currently writing? I feel as if I never got a good mental picture of Quentin and his sweetheart, Alice. I can’t define what their faces look like, except that Alice had black straight hair and that here eyes were sallow when Quentin first met her. I wished that there was more details in certain areas, and less in others. Maybe I read over those parts too quickly? That is a possibility, but even as they got older he never seemed to make clear definitions on what their features were doing. I know that facial features don’t change that much in 5 or 6 years, but they do change, especially when you go from age 17 to 23 or 24. But like I said, I may have skimmed over those parts. If I did, feel free to disregard all that you have so far read.
Lets snap back to reality (take that, Eminem), or the reality factor his book incorporates.
Grossman’s attention to real world reactions is something I greatly admired in this book. Yet, the real world-ness was also something that also distanced me from the book. ”But Steven,” you say “you can’t have it both ways! Its either a good or bad thing. Make up your mind!” Trust me, I feel the same way, yet, I wish there was something more fairy tale-y to the story. I believe my struggle with this culminates at the end of the story.
I love real world endings in movies: a group of kids wander into the house of a crazed serial killer and they all die, the monster destroys the city and no one can stop him, the protagonist is killed, etc. These things make me enjoy movies because they sometimes become so over the top that its nice to have a director bring it back down to earth. With this story, I was pulling for a happy ending the whole time. When the protagonist fucked it up, then became overly angry at his girlfriend (I said there would be spoilers, but I’m trying to not give details away either), and when they sort of made up, I was stoked. I thought to myself, “Fuck yeah, Q! You fucked up, and she fucked up too, but you need to forgive her cause you love her, and because it’s your fault that she ended up fucking up! C’mon, don’t be an asshole, be a MAN and deal with the consequences of your actions! You’re almost there!” I was rooting for him. I truly was. But that “real world” (I put quotations around it because they were in a fantasy land when it happened) stepped in and changed everything. I felt deceived, hoodwinked, or whatever else you want to call it. It wasn’t what I expected, which in retrospect, is a great thing. It feels like lazy writing when the author goes with the standard ending. Yet, I felt that out of countless stories I have read in my life, none more than this book, and the characters within the pages, deserved the standard happy ending.
While the ending wasn’t what I had hoped for it to be, I feel as if that is what Mr. Grossman intended: Life isn’t always what you hoped for, sometimes its worse, other times its more than you can imagine, but regardless of what happens, there’s always something new and exciting just waiting be discovered. You just need to keep your heart open. Or maybe he just wrote a kick ass book and I’m tying way too much shit into it that really isn’t there.
You, random person who fell on to this “blog”, read this book. You won’t be disappointed.
Oh, and New York Times, I am waiting on my check.